Sort of discussing and debating at the same time. IF you had 2-4 weeks time(during Cocoa Beach flat spells) and were only looking to consistently surf, where would you go? With the quicker, dirtier, cheaper, and less crowded options listed first. Where would you go?

My list would start with

1 El Sal

2 Nica

3 Dominican Republic

4 Puerto Rico

5 South Costa

6 Secret Spot by Volusia county?

Any places which you could safely forego the rental car and also consider primitive camping to cut down the cost?